Monday, January 11, 2010

"Don't Panic."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/01/10/AR2010011002143.html

In his most recent article, "Don't Panic", Newsweek editor Fareed Zakaria suggests that an emotional, heavy-handed reaction to the attempted airline bombing last month may be unwarranted, and may in fact be exactly the sort of response the attack was intended to provoke. Certainly this suggestion runs counter to the impulses of most readers (as well as policymakers) and is therefore an "unacceptable proposition."

He cites the unique nature of terrorism as an instrument of effecting change. The real physical damage of a terrorist attack is not important; what matters is the psychological impact. If it did not trigger fear and anger, it would not be effective. Zakaria suggests that Al-Qaeda claimed responsibility for the botched attack because, although it failed to claim any lives, it still elicited the desire response.

He interprets the attack as an ill-conceived potshot at the US, that indicates Al-Qaeda's inability to mount more effective, large-scale attacks. He argues that to further stifle air travel with security procedures of dubious efficacy would not make the nation safer, and would only serve to dignify a rather desperate and amateurish attack.

rhetorical situation

So, if you didn't guess my topic is drug abuse. Drugs are not only harmful to yourself, but they intern are dangerous for those around them. I mean it really hurts the abusers too, they pull teeth out, scratch skin off, jump off buildings, have braincell loss, and an addiction which leads to crimes such as stealing for money and the next high. It just has a ripple effect. Starting in the drug users own circles, it hurts their families, friends, classmates. It hurts the families, because it alters moods and causes the abusers to do really stupid things and they shirk responsibilities within the home, causing strained relationships. The friends, because no matter how many cool friends do it with them, they are still setting a horrid example. The classmates, everyone knows who abuses the drugs, in a high stupor the abusers could potentially harm their classmates by driving them around, or involving them in their crimes. They don't even have to know the people they hurt, the person they hit while driving, or beat up because they thought that they were a crazy colored pinata. The biggest issue that I find with drug abuse, is drug abusers with children. They are hurting their children. I have seen poor little crack babies, heard horror stories about mothers boiling their children's feet...it goes on. Life is only about their next fix. Nothing else.

The audiences to address would probably be the drug abusers themselves or the age just under the age most kids start abusing. 12ish maybe? You can maybe influence the abuser to realize that life isn't really that bad and do the same for the young kids. Just curbing what causes people to run to drugs is a big help in their life. I feel like this issue is relevant to all people, everyone knows an abuser.

The genres to reach the audience could potentially be short stories, allegorical stories, poems, songs...there are lots of ways to reach people.

More sex is safer sex

Now you cant really find a more unacceptable title then this one. And I totally do not agree with what he is saying. But I don't have to, I just have to find something that is an initially Unacceptable claim and this fits the bill. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/76faa124-f0f0-11db-838b-000b5df10621.html This is a book by steven Landburg that tries to apply the art of economics to Sexual promiscuity. In there he states that if more people were promiscuous then sex would be safer for everyone. Even though this appears ridiculous he makes the argument that if more people where sexually active then there would be not be a small circle of people with STD's, rather a larger circle of generally "clean" people and therefore everyone would be less likely to get an STD. He makes the argument that sexual restraint is a pollution to those more promiscious. if one was to agree with his dogmatic logic they may come around to his way of thinking and find his initially unacceatable claim to be accetable. But I doubt it.

Raise the legal driving age for teens?

An issue that comes up every now and then is one of if the legal driving age for teens should be raised. Here is a article written by Karl Chisholm; http://www.blueoregon.com/2009/10/raise-the-legal-driving-age-for-teens.html.
His claim is that we need to raise the legal driving age from what it is now. It seemed that the general population that responded did not agree primarily those who are parents of teen drivers.
In his reasonings he gives some statistics that "the rate of crashes, fatal and nonfatal, per mile driven for 16-year-old drivers is almost 10 times the rate for drivers ages 30 to 59" and that traffic accidents are the leading killer of american teens. I like how on the subject for his reasons he didn't just give negative reasons but that he gave some of the positive benefits that would come from raising the age. although some of them were more assuming than more facts. none the less it at least made me think about those things such as traffic and the assumption that the teenagers would increase there cardiovascular activities more. Over all I felt that he did give some good reasons, and specifically at the beginning of his article, he presented his reasons and assumptions well, but for some reason on his last paragraph he seemed to lose some of my trust. he seemed to be very one sided and I feel he didn't think much about what his audience that will have differing opinions claimed. Example as I read I was often saying in my mind "But what about....." He should have read read Writing and Rhetoric haha :)

Stem Cell Research

An issue with much ethical controversy is the topic of stem cell research. In an article by Janet Rowley, http://www.usnews.com/articles/opinion/2009/03/23/embryonic-stem-cell-research-does-too-much-good-to-be-evil-says-janet-rowley.html, the claim is made that stem cell research does too much good to be a bad thing. This claim is quite unacceptable to people because of the issues with using embryos to do the research.
To support her claim she uses the logical reasoning that the embryonic cells, from in vitro fertilization, will basically just be thrown away if not used. Also she tells of how scientists have been very willing to work with the restrictions put on them and have tried to use alternative methods, so it is not as if they are only doing that which people might not agree with. They are doing it to benefit others, so it is not for 'evil' intentions. Yet stem cells offer so much and research has not found a better source to help so many people. Through using these statements the author is giving reasons to the audience that make sense and is being accurate in her research on what is happening in the labs.

Abortion

At the site http://www.leaderu.com/orgs/probe/docs/arg-abor.html Kerby Anderson is making a claim on how Abortion is bad in all different aspects of life. This is definitely an initially unacceptable claim. Although I agree with his claim there are many who do not at all. We can see that in the amount of abortions we have each year. Just in U.S. since 1973, when it became legal, there have been approximately 46 million abortions. Kerby Anderson’s claim is not accepted by all Americans. He starts off using the bible as an argument against abortion. He uses a couple of areas in Psalms, he uses a lot of different scriptures throughout the bible. As he ends he really focuses on a legal code in Exodus concerning a prematurely birth due to a man hitting a women, if this happens that man will die. He concludes that a baby inside the womb has the same legal status as a baby outside the womb and so that it is unlawful to kill a baby inside the womb. For those who do not believe in the Bible he goes on to use medical arguments against Abortion. Some of the main points were the definition of death. One definition is the cessation of heartbeat. So if that means death, than does the start of a heartbeat mean life which starts the 18th day in the womb. He continues the argument by going to legal arguments against abortion. He says that since the Supreme Court does not know how to define when life begins they should have acted “as if” life was in the womb, since they did not know. But they didn’t and ended up overturning state laws that protected the fetus. Lastly he uses philosophical arguments. He gives some of the definitions people have for life or human beings. But if we followed those then we could have an infanticide. Throughout his argument he tries to reach all types of people, Christians, Doctors, and those in law.

Should Old People Be Allowed to Drive?

A classic debate is whether or not old people should be allowed to drive. This author is passionately against old people driving. Follow this link: http://www.squidoo.com/oldpeopleshouldnotdrive
He claims that at the age of seventy-four or older the crash rates are too high. But he also points out that the crash rates are just as high as anyone under twenty-four. Therefore if anyone over seventy-four year olds shouldn't be able than shouldn't anyone under twenty-four also not be able to drive? The internet is used more by young adults and if they are reading this, they are not going to want to get their driving privlidges taken away. His claims are then backed by a few random statistics, some stories of crashes the elderly have gotten into and some funny videos at the bottom the site. I'm sure their are plenty of statistics, stories and videos about the dumb accidents younger people have had. Nobody's perfect and I agree that everyone should be tested regularly to make sure they are capable of getting behind the wheel. But his discrimination towards old people overall is a weak claim.

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Coloured lasers treat epilepsy?

A January, 2010, BBC health-related article claims that coloured lasers can be used to treat brain disorders, such as epilepsy. Apparently, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology has discovered a way to use yellow and blue flashing lasers to shut down brain activity.
Here is the link to the artile: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/8441983.stm
The claim is initially unacceptable because lasers and epilepsy does not seem a common connection, nor a feasible one. The reader automatically questions, "what do colorful lights have anything to do with brain disorders?," and, "how can lasers cure seizures?" The answer to these questions is obviously not self-explanatory, and this is what begins the argument.
The article goes on to give details of the study and how and why it works. The author is giving reasons for the reader to believe the claim. The study revolves around two genes that need light to make energy. They are called Arch and Mach. Arch and Mac contain the genetic code for light-activated proteins. MIT has engineered brain neurons to express Arch and Mach. In testing they were able to control the brains of animals with yellow and blue lasers because the light activates proteins that lower the voltage in the neurons and stops them from generating an electrical signal. The researchers are working on targeting specific parts of the brain to shut down, eliminating seizures.
The author uses scientific facts and studies that show experiment outcomes to back up his claim. By the end of the article, a clear assumption is made that yellow and blue flashing lasers may one day cure brain disorders.

-Lydia Nelson

Correcting Myths about Job Interviews

One of the news stories on the Yahoo! homepage is about myths or job interviews and why they are myths. One myth in particular says "Do not show weakness in an interview." This claim seems unacceptable because, when in an interview, you think you should always be trying to put you best foot forward. Revealing a weakness to a potential employer seems like a backward step in the interview process.
The authors of the article use expert opinions to prove to the reader that this statement really is a myth. They talked with workers for companies that help people find and keep jobs, to see what to really do during an interview. One of the things that they said to prove their point about the myth is that if you are asked about a weakness and you talk your way around it in such a manner that you don't answer the question, the interview can see right through it and know that you are not being honest with them. A potential employer is more likely to hire someone with a flaw, but is honest, than someone who pretends that they are perfect. The experts give the advice that, if asked, you should give one true flaw or weakness that you have. Make sure to also include how you are able to work through this disadvantage or how you deal with it in a positive way. Once you have done this, allow the interviewer to move on to something different, and don't dwell on the subject any longer.
By the end of the article you, as a reader, are able to see where the authors of the article are coming from. You may not agree, but fromt their reasoning you now find yourself thinking about their statement and more open to their ideas.
The article can be found at:
http://hotjobs.yahoo.com/career-articles-interview_myths_that_keep_you_from_landing_the_job-1026

Saturday, January 9, 2010

Immigrants and the Economy

A recent study published by the Center for American Progress and the American Immigration Council claims that legalizing the unauthorized immigrants in the United States, and easing strict immigration laws, will help the economy. This claim is unacceptable to the audience initially because it contradicts what the common belief is. That belief centers around the notion that unauthorized immigrants steal jobs away from legal citizens, create a burden on the health system as well as the federal government.

This claim is made acceptable to the audience through a few different ways. The study examines three different scenarios that would affect the United States economy. The first is that deportation would result in a loss of $2.6 trillion in gross domestic product (GDP) over ten years. An assumption is used here to link the reason (loss in GDP) with the claim (legalizing the immigrants would boost the economy). The assumption is that the immigrants would be buying and consuming products here in the United States and the money that they spend would stimulate the economy while deporting them would damage it.

Another way that this claim is made acceptable is through detailing rising costs with the United States Border Patrol. Since 1992, their budget has increased 714 percent and by making the proposed changes will allow this to be reduced and allow the funds to be allocated in different ways. Statistics are used here to show that because of stricter immigration laws, more funds have to be directed to the Border Patrol while immigration continues to rise, which supports their assumed argument that the current system is ineffective.

Although the claim may still be unacceptable to many people, the researchers used logical assumptions, statistics, and long-term research to help prove how their claim is acceptable.


Article: http://www.cnn.com/2010/POLITICS/01/07/immigration.economy/index.html

Actual study: http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2010/01/raising_the_floor.html

Acai Berry Claim

Alright everyone has heard of the super fruit Acai berry. When I first saw an add for it I thought, "It is just a fruit. It isn't going to help you drop weight or miraculously cure cancer or anything like the adds said it would". The claim seemed unacceptable. I really couldn't see the benefits, but as I continued to see adds and webpages dedicated to this seemingly innocuous fruit I realized there was something that was getting everyone hooked. First the testimonials on the fruit were incredible. Oprah and every televised doctor seemed to uphold it. Next the actual nutrients attributed to the fruit, that scientists endorsed, were enough to make me even more curious. It is rich with antioxidants. Antioxidants are very good for you, so it is possible that the Acai berry could have much more going for it too. Then the fact that it is completely organic. There are no pesticides to harm the body. What could be better. Oh and don't let me forget that it will completely wash all toxins out of the body, as one of it's other claims to fame. This website I found shows what the benefits are as well as gives incredibly heartwarming testimonials http://www.amazonthunder.com/ . This claim is exactly what a good argument entails. At first the claim seems unrealistic, but when you dig deeper you come to realize that it has so much logical proof coming from all sorts of sources. It could be entirely possible that it is the superfruit it is said to be.

Obama's Healthcare Plan

An issue that is constantly being debated today is President Obama’s healthcare plan. In his youtube video “The Obama Plan in Four Minutes”, Obama explains his plan for healthcare. This video can be found at: http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/. In his video, the President makes a few claims that are aimed at convincing the American people that his plan for healthcare will be the most cost-effective and best way to ensure healthcare for everyone. One of the main claims that Obama makes is that universal healthcare will not increase taxes. This claim is initially unacceptable because providing healthcare for every American, no matter what their economic status, seems impossible without increasing taxes. Obama states that his healthcare plan will not add more money to our already substantial national debt and will make healthcare affordable to all Americans. He seems to avoid this issue by focusing his argument on how great our new healthcare system will be, without addressing the price tag. Throughout his argument, I can see the benefits of Obama’s plan, yet I am unable to tell how exactly all these new reform programs will make healthcare more affordable. Maybe I just don’t know the specifics of Obama’s plan, but it seems to me that by making healthcare cheaper for someone, it makes taxes go up for someone else. Although Obama’s claim states that healthcare will be cheaper for all, I fail to see how this could actually happen without increasing taxes at some point.

Cats feel superior to dogs

On the great website of Yahoo! they have a few "news" posts that they cycle through for the day. On such was a video of a cat ridding a Roomba (I believe they are those robot vacuum cleaners that roam around our home vacuuming so you do not have to). The caption for this video on the Yahoo! page read as such: "When it comes to dogs, some cats think they're superior — but this one thinks he's invincible."

To read the Yahoo! post go to : http://m.www.yahoo.com/?r0=1263071513
To watch the cat go to: http://video.yahoo.com/network/100284668?v=6646643&l=3774740

The claim that they are making about this video is that when it comes to dogs, some cats think they are superior.
The reason they use is that this cat is riding a Roomba and swatting a dog which apparently makes that cat feel invincible.
The complete arguement with the claim and reason is: When it comes to dogs, some cats think they are superior because this cat is riding a Roomba and swatting a dog, making him feel invincible.
The assumption they are using is: Whatever cat is riding a Roomba will make that cat think that they are superior to dogs.

The audience at first could understand that some cats do infact think that they are superior to dogs becuase of their own expereinces with observing some cats taunting acts infront of dogs. So the assumption they use could be valid to audience members if they understand that some cats act as though they are superior to dogs. However, though some of the audience my not initally accept that cats feel superior to dogs. The audience is drawn to the claim because at first it does not seem acceptable with the reason they are using to back up the claim.

Personally, I think this arguement is very weak, though it does draw the attention of viewers becuase of the unexpected video photoage. How many people have seen a cat riding a Roomba? I haven't until this moment. But just because a cat is riding a Roomba and swatting at a dog does not mean the cat feels superior to dogs. Cats do weird things just becuase they can and no one can actually figure out what the thought process is of a cat. You cannot get into a cat's head and see their thoughts. The assumption they are using is guilty of commiting the fallacy of jumping on the bandwagon (just becuase many people believe that the claim is true does not actually mean that it is true).

Friday, January 8, 2010

The Issues.

As a member of the BYU community, I face the following issues:

1. I really don't care what your major is, but we still have to talk about it.

2. The girl at the frozen yogurt shop has BYU guys trying to pick her up all the time, and is accordingly unfriendly to me.

3. Utah kids say "filled" when they mean "field", and "melk" when they mean "milk", and "heel" when they mean "hill." Oh, and "idiz" when they mean "ideas". It shouldn't bother me, but it does.

4. The Bookstore is pretty shady, I guess. Parking is pretty tight, too. On the other hand, famine, slavery, genocide, warlordism, etc. are pretty much non-issues on campus, so that's nice.
Issue 1:
Parking for students is very frustrating! There seems to be 100's of "A Lots" but very few "Y Lots", and the few there "Y lots" there are, they are usually the farthest ones away!

Issue 2:
Many of the teachers are using E-text and different online web cites for there classes that seem to be more of a pain than a blessings at times! sometimes i wish the would just keep it simple!

Issue 3:
Traffic is never ending.... they seem to spend thousands of dollars and yet it never ends!

Issue 4:
In Massachusetts they allow driving down the emergency lane during traffic hours. which speeds up the flow of traffic but at the same time the issue is for those how really need to use the emergency lane and its bumper to bumper traffic.

Community Issues in S.A.

When they rebuilt the Sports Center, the seats were 2/3’s bigger than the previous size. Texas has a huge population of teenage parents. I have personally witnessed many pregnant teens while in high school. The community has an increasing amount of night clubs and bars that seem to crop up out of nowhere daily. This is increasing the chance that many more drunk accidents will occur. In the same way the drug dealing and substance abuse that goes on is increasing and seems to hit kids of younger and younger ages.

Rexburg has Issues

Issue 1: Parking

If you thought that the parking at BYU was bad BYU-I is horrible. There are extremely few designated parking lots which has caused an over flow into the public parking domains.

Issue 2: sub divisions

My home town is very small and open. How ever the recent influx of people has led to generally uncontrolled expansion. This has caused both logistical and scenic problems.

Issue 3: Public Schools

Along with an increase of the population there has been increased demand placed upon the Public school which have become increasingly overwhelmed.

Issue 4: Traffic

Rexburg was initially designed with low traffic roads that have been unable to meet the demands of the current population.

Issue 5: Snow removal

High snow levels coupled with high speed winds have led to difficult navigation across roads that are not regularly plowed Community: home town Rexburg

.

Issues in my High School

  • Sex before marriage is often a debate, especially among the upper classmen. It is a debate between the religious point of view that sex before marriage is wrong, and it is their right (as long as both individuals “love” each other and are willing) to have sex with or without a condom.·
  • The rising tuition cost put on the colleges in my home state, placed there by the state government has also been a huge debate. Many student s are against the extremely high rates at which the tuition costs are rising. Many feel that they will not be able to afford schooling and then will not be able to get a job which all would help increase the worsening economy predicament.·
  • Gay rights is an ongoing issue. It is mainly a debate between people that have religious back grounds that believe that same sex attraction is wrong and between people that believe that anything goes, it is their right to “love” whom they want to “love.” And many gay people want everyone to accept them for who they are so that they can be open to the public about their affiliations without being scrutinized about their sexual attractions.
  • The dress code continues to be another issue, especially among the females. Many believe that it is their right to wear (or the lack thereof) whatever they please. But there are others that just “don’t want to see any of that.”

“Issues” within Chino Hills, California

  1. There seems to be a wide gap between the political/ moral standpoints of the parents and the children. This may indicate a lack of adequate communication within families.

  1. There are occasionally children playing hooky and smoking in parking lots. Someone should intervene on their behalf, if only by talking to them.

  1. There are still some street corners that can use a stop sign – a three second stall surely is worth the possibility of saving a life!

  1. Neighbors, even those living next to each other, rarely visit or even interact with each other. There should be more social events for the community.

Issues in my Community

Honor code: I have heard many students complain about the Honor Code, calling it too restrictive. One thing that they fail to take into consideration is the mission and purpose of Brigham Young University. This university is not solely designed to pump out well-trained graduates; it has a higher purpose. Students at BYU are meant to be an example of the Church which sponsors this university and therefore are held to a higher standard.

Special treatment of athletes: Free clothes, private tutors for whatever class they choose, an X-Box fanatic's dream set up at a bowl game; it pays to be a collegiate level athlete. You have to wonder why athletes get so much special treatment when most of them will not play their sport after graduation.

Casual dress: I once read that a student was strongly opposed to casual dress (shorts, t-shirts, flip flops) on campus as it detracts from the learning environment. This attitude is rather juvenile as casual dress does not mean somebody is casual with their education.

Bookstore prices: Every student on campus has experienced the exorbitant prices at the Bookstore. Like me, I am sure most students feel very strongly that the policies and prices of the Bookstore are ridiculous and do not make much sense.