Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Monday, March 8, 2010

Ethics

Ethics is so much now and days about who gets to information first. Everything is a race to publish first just so that you don't have to deal with plagiarism issues. It is so easy to plagiarize, even if you aren't trying. In fact it is easy to plagiarize even when you are trying not to. Anyone doing research needs to be sure to record all the sources that they find so that when they write, they can cite all sources. Not plagarizing is difficult!
We have a responsibility to do whatever we can to not plagiarized as well as influence others to do the same.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Ethics of Writing (late)

Plagiarism is a complex ethical issue. Good writing is intended to inspire imitation. We write so that others will take our ideas and make them their own; and if they are writers, adopting our expressions in defense of the same ideas would be "the sincerest form of flattery". In fact, this may be the greatest satisfaction of writing well--to hear your ideas spread to other people, particularly in the very same words.

A good writer would not fear this sort of plagiarism--in fact, many crave it, and all great writers engage in it themselves. We could not write in modern English if we were forbidden to imitate Shakespeare. There would be no such thing as the "romantic comedy" if screenwriters couldn't wantonly plagiarize Jane Austen. The sort of plagiarism that is frowned upon is lazy, thoughtless plagiarism--committed for money or academic distinctions, without acknowledging the source.

Writers have a responsibility to their readers to corroborate their statements, so that they can follow the path of the writer's research and judge for themselves whether their sources are accurate and credible.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

ETHICS... oh boy (Revisted)

As you guys might have noticed, Ty and I have the same post. He was the one that actually wrote it I just copied it and changed my time stamp. I am trying to make a point.

So much of what we consider plagiarism has to do with Karios of writing, who was first. Even if the second person got the same idea by his/her own means as the first they are considered having plagiarized. It is no longer his “idea.” It’s not so much being original as being the first original. You may have believed that Ty copied me on the soul basis that mine was published before his when in fact it was the other way around. And who is to say that I did not have the same idea as Ty but he just beat me to the punch. My idea would no longer be “original” even though I thought of it independently.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Ethics

What is so bad about plagiarism? It makes sense to copy down some information, pass it off as your own, get a good grade, and call it a day. For me, there are two major reasons why we need to avoid plagiarism like the plague.

1.) Responsibility to the reader: as a writer, you obviously have responsibilities to your audience. I feel that among them are the need to provide readers with factual information from credible sources. But this does not give you license to take whatever information you want and pass it off as your own. To me it is the same as robbing a bank. You are stealing material that you did not provide the hard work to earn.

2.) Responsibility to yourself: this may sound very sappy but I believe it to be true. Learning is not simply about getting a grade; it is about the process of learning how to think. It is about discovery. I feel that you cheat yourself by plagiarizing. Yes, it takes more effort to do all the work by yourself but I think you will honestly feel better about yourself if you do the work rather than stealing from others. No matter what the Daily Universe reports about the "gray" areas in the Honor Code remember, gray is just diluted black.

ETHICS... oh boy

So in my uneducated opinion I feel that Plagiarism is like stealing.... and stealing is very bad! Obviously plagiarizing has some major ethical issues in terms of stealing ideas but I think that on a personal level for the plagiarizer it is much more harmful! First of all he/she does by plagiarizing is simply take the easy way out. With things like "copy and paste" the plagiarizer does not really gain anything of real value for themselves, yes maybe a A in the class if he/she is a student but one day their lack of knowledge they would have gained other wise will come to bite them in the butt. Also I think that is has it moral consequences, the more and more a society leans toward dishonesty in any area of life... its like a plague that spreads through out every aspect of life. I think we should all try our best not to plagiarize by simply putting a little more effort in what we do to gain a much greater reward.

ETHICS... oh boy

So in my uneducated opinion I feel that Plagiarism is like stealing.... and stealing is very bad! Obviously plagiarizing has some major ethical issues in terms of stealing ideas but I think that on a personal level for the plagiarizer it is much more harmful! First of all he/she does by plagiarizing is simply take the easy way out. With things like "copy and paste" the plagiarizer does not really gain anything of real value for themselves, yes maybe a A in the class if he/she is a student but one day their lack of knowledge they would have gained other wise will come to bite them in the butt. Also I think that is has it moral consequences, the more and more a society leans toward dishonesty in any area of life... its like a plague that spreads through out every aspect of life. I think we should all try our best not to plagiarize by simply putting a little more effort in what we do to gain a much greater reward.


Ethics

The point of research is to find the truth. Without ethics research and writing could be very dangerous. When writing and researching one should be ethical just as they would when giving a speech. No one would want to get up and tell lies to an audience. At least those who were honest would not do so. It is the same with writing. Even if the audiece cannot be seen and does not seem very real there is indeed an audience who will read the material. It seems so obvious, yet I think it is easy for people to write and forget that writing is not just a personal matter.

We are responsible to give people credit for what we have used. It just makes sense that people should be given credit for the work they spent such time and effort on. Also giving credit to our sources gives us as the writer more credit. Who wants to read a research paper that does not have reliable information to back it up?

We owe it to our readers to give them the access to more information on the research topic. Also they simply just deserve to know the truth. We must avoid plagarism because if we do not then it will create confusion and hurt our ethos. Once again plagarism is just simply dishonest and when we write we need to be sure to distinguish what comes from us and from others.

Ethics Dilemma

The issue with ethics and writing is an old one, one that spans many eons of time. To me however, the dilemma has modernized thanks to new media and the influences of the modern society. Ethics and writing has become a battlefield where writers of all mediums come to ensue battle about things like using rhetoric to subliminally mask meanings or being too biased in coverage of topics and providing information. Our responsibilities as writers are to inform the intended audience about our point, try to persuade them to believe what we believe (or at least change their outlook) and try to get the audience engaged or interested in our writing. We may show bias, but do so creatively; we may use rhetoric and use it sneakily, but we must do it well.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Is Fox News spawn of Satan?

At the beginning of the class, I expressed my distate for Pathos. I feel uncomfortable employing emotions to change people. Maybe it's my my rugged manliness that causes the conflict. As Oscar Wilde said, "A sentimentalist is one who desires to have the luxury of an emotion without paying for it." I will eventually need to overcome the restrictions of my sex and sap up my writing if I want to be truly successful.

But my discomfort raises a question: is it ethical to manipulate people through powerful writing, emotion aside? Just like Jedi Mind Tricks, writing can have a powerful effect on the weak minded; it has the potential to raise mobs. Also, there are scores of people out there who will defend a position that they've read about just because they've read about it. I was one of them. My 8th grade year, after reading Atlas Shrugged, I was an avid Objectionist. However after further research and study, I find many aspects of that philosophy ridiculous. It is unethical only to present one side of an argument?

No. It's not.

And even if it was unethical, there's no way to prevent manipulation. Bias is inherent. It's unethical for you as a reader to only read one side of the argument.

Christmas is in 298 days!

As a history teaching major, I have realized that we owe everything that we know about the past to historians that have come before. When writing a scholarly paper, historians compile something called a historiography. A historiography is a summary of what past scholars have said about a certain topic. This shows that as historians, we respect the opinions and insights that others have been able to give and we build on what they have said before, adding our own insights and personal views. This is just one example of how important it is to give credit to those that have done significant work before us. This is why plagiarism is such an issue. By taking someone else’s work and calling it your own, you are taking away all the credit that they should be getting for countless hours of work. As writers, we have a responsibility to report our opinions and as much of the truth as we know. Whatever we write should be either our own thoughts or the thoughts of others, with proper citation.

Ethical Writing

Basically the ethics of writing is telling the truth and nothing but the truth in all that you do, or write. Do not change something so that it benefits you. That also goes for when you are researching. When you use someon else's research you need to site it, let others know that you were not the one who came up with that or discovered that, you need to give credit to others. We need to be fair to those that did do the work and got the information and to do that we need to cite where we got it and either quote is exactly or use our own words completly while still citing where you got that information. This also helps the readers, it shows the reader that you are using reliable sources and just not making it up. Here at BYU plagiarism is against the honor code, but it is still completely wrong no matter where you are or what school you go to. It is lying, you are taking someone's credit that you do not deserve. You are also not doing or showing your own work.

Ethics of Writing

The entire point of writing is in the fact that it is meant to be read. As such, the writer's duty to the reader is integral. Coherency in grammar and sentence structure is a must, as is presentation - the proof that one's writing contains proper evidence and is well researched. This does not apply to only essay writing; even in works of fiction, one does not want to read about an act or profession that the writer actually has no experience in. For example, Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms draws credibility from the fact that its author served in the military himself, and could be taken seriously. Those who have set the groundwork before the writer should have homage made to them - in some cases, it would be plagiarism not to, depending on the amount of impact made in their field. Of course, plagiarism itself is frowned upon by the writing community - when writing, one is presenting a personal voice and idea; some say that everything that is written should be able to bring some new idea to the table, no matter how small or subtle. Plagiarism not only steals another person's words, but also their persona and their thoughts. Applied to the physical world, such an act would be called "body-snatching". This would also be frowned upon by society.

To write or not to write...

I think one of the biggest problems with writing and research is plagiarism. Not properly crediting someone for their work is unfair to them. They deserve the reward for their hard work. You wouldn't take credit from someone who scored the game winning shot in a basketball game and you shouldn't take credit from someone who said something you liked. It is the writers responsibility to their audience to tell the truth and to give them correct information. Yes you can lie and bend facts but what good does that do overall? That doesn't help anyone! Just like how we have the Honor Code (and there was a good article in the Daily Universe about that today) and it's up to us to follow it with exactness. We could easily cut corners but in the end that doesn't help anyone. Like Thumper said to Bambi "If you can't say anything nice(or correct), don't say nothing at all" :)

Ethics

The ethics of writing and research stem from two things (I believe): no plagiarism, and always telling the absolute truth. Especially with a research paper, I really don't think it is fair to say you are giving hard cold facts when really you are just spouting off what you want in order to get the effect/affect (I forget which one) you want. We have a responsibility to our readers to provide research that was fairly attained and correctly interpreted.
We are to avoid plagiarism because of three things (I believe): (because if plagiarize) We are cheeting the public, we are cheeting the original writer, and we are cheeting ourselves. How can we grow and understand if we don't actually process our own unique way of seeing things? We can add to the knowledge of our world just by putting in our own input and seeing in a different way--in our own different way.
It's interesting that we're talking about this in class, because this topic just came up in my Women's Studies class. We were viewing pictures of pretty recent magazine covers that had images of celebrities with fake bodies. It was interesting to discuss how damaging the pictures could be to the public. Our perception of what is "real beauty" is not even close to being "real"!!

Monday, March 1, 2010

Foreman give Cameron her credit please...

I would have to say that writing and research ethics are similar if you are doing a research paper. You should have respect for the people who gave you the research you needed for your paper and credit them. You wouldn't want someone else to steal your ideas and call them their own. So you shouldn't do it to them. On an episode of House M.D., Foreman stole Cameron's ideas and used it to write his own article. She was very ticked. It was unprofessional. You should also credit those who gave you the ideas or background research. If he was going to use her ideas, he could have at least accredited her. The responsibility to the readers is to be as knowledgeable on the subject as possible. As well as make the reading enjoyable, not writing a stiff boring piece. It would lack interest and no one will read it. Avoiding plagiarism is extremely important because you could be sued or kicked out of BYU.

I have horrible titles for these blogs....

Plagerism is simply the stealing of ideas. And stealing is wrong. What happened to "Thou shalt not steal"? Plagerism is huge. Especially on the internet because it is so easy to simply copy and paste something from a webpage onto a word document and call it yours. We have to site our sources to clear all doubt that this was not your idea and that you are not taking it from someone else. If nothing was ever sited we would never know what was credible information and what wasn't. Siting sources allows the credit to go to those who deserve it (or those who shouldn't deserve credibility for stupid ideas) and builds their credibility and their authority (or decreases). Avoiding plagerisms keeps the writen world in order. There are laws for a reason. They keep order and stability and in the end laws make us free when they are obeyed.